The Eisenhower Matrix: A helpful time management tool – with limits worth knowing

What it does well, where it falls short for ADHD and concussion recovery, and what tends to work better.

Managing tasks and time comes up frequently in my conversations — with clients living with ADHD or concussion/TBI, and with parents supporting their children through a particularly busy or challenging season. Many of us know the feeling of an endless to-do list or when everything feels urgent, and the cognitive load of just deciding what to tackle first can be completely overwhelming. 

The Eisenhower Matrix is a great tool to support task management and productivity. For many stressed-and-stretched parents, it works well as a starting point. But for those of us navigating ADHD, concussion, or other executive functioning challenges, it can fall short in ways that feel frustrating and even a little defeating.

The Eisenhower Matrix: A time management and prioritization tool

The idea is straightforward: you take everything living in your head, do a brain dump onto paper, and sort each task into one of four buckets based on two things — how urgent it is and how important it is.

Do it now

Urgent + Important → These need your attention now.

For parents: This could be follow-up appointments, a 504 meeting, or your child having a really hard day.

For students: Perhaps this is finishing a lab report due tonight.

Schedule it

Important, not urgent → These matter, but perhaps not this minute.

For parents: This could be building a recovery plan, researching providers, or bigger-picture school conversations.

For students: This could be reviewing chemistry notes for a test next Friday or creating a monthly study plan.

Delegate it

Urgent, not important → Things that feel pressing but don't require you specifically.

For parents: Can someone else handle carpool or laundry this week?

For students: Answering "quick question" messages from a classmate (for information they could look up themselves).

Let it go

Not urgent, not important → Things sneaking onto your list that honestly don't belong there anymore

For parents: Reorganizing the kitchen cabinets or making homemade cupcakes for the bake sale instead of buying them.

For students: Reorganizing your study space again instead of studying or mindless scrolling on social media.

When we're stressed or stretched thin, our executive function system is overtaxed and everything can feel like it belongs in that first bucket. The matrix helps us slow down just enough to see that it doesn't – and that clarity can be a real relief.

Where it genuinely helps

The Eisenhower Matrix helps to move decision-making outside of your brain by providing a visual scaffold. Instead of asking an overwhelmed nervous system to self-organize, the matrix provides an external structure that supports clearer thinking when everything feels equally important or impossible.

The Delegate or Let it Go/Delete quadrants can also be genuinely freeing for people who struggle to say no or let go of tasks. Sometimes simply seeing something land in "not mine, not now" offers the permission needed to release it. 

Where it falls short – especially for ADHD, TBI, and concussion recovery

The challenge with the Eisenhower Matrix is that it asks you to use the very skills affected most often with executive functioning challenges – 

• prioritization of ranking tasks by importance and urgency

• cognitive flexibility and abstract reasoning to shift your perspective across two dimensions at once

• working memory to hold the criteria in mind while evaluating each task

• decision-making and judgment about what's truly urgent vs. important

• self-awareness of your own tasks, time, and capacity 

• and more. 

For many people navigating ADHD, traumatic brain injury, or post-concussion cognitive symptoms, the categorization process itself can become so mentally taxing that you've used up all your energy before a single task gets done.

The Schedule It (Important, Not Urgent) quadrant in particular is where things most often break down. These are the tasks that matter most for long-term management and well-being – and they're exactly the ones most likely to never get done. 

That said, I don't want to throw the whole tool out.

If you want to try it, here's how I'd adapt it

• Keep it small -– limit each quadrant to your biggest priorities only, not a full brain dump

• Do it with someone – a coach, therapist, accountability partner, or trusted friend changes the experience entirely

• Start slowly with only major items, not a comprehensive task inventory

What tends to work better for EF-different brains

For clients with ADHD or concussion/TBI, these approaches tend to be more accessible and more effective day-to-day:

• A simple "Top 3" list – just three things for the day, nothing more

  
  

• Using a "Now/Not Now" binary to start

  
  

• Body doubling – working alongside someone, in-person or virtually, to support initiation

  
  

• Asking one question: "What is the one thing I can do right now?" – no sorting required

  
  

• The Impact-Effort Matrix as an alternative – it replaces the abstract urgency/importance judgment with something more concrete: how much effort does this take, and what's the payoff? Identifying some Quick Wins (High Impact / Low Effort) can feel very rewarding and help build momentum.

  
  

The bottom line: No tool works for everyone. What matters most is finding a system that reduces the burden on YOUR brain -- not adds to it. For someone managing concussion or EF challenges, that usually means something simpler, more concrete, and built with a coach to help you tailor it to your specific needs.

---

Jenny Traver, MS, CCC-SLP, CBIS

If you're finding that time management, prioritization and cognitive load are among the harder parts of this season -- for yourself or your child -- the right scaffolding can make all the difference. If you're curious about finding the simple systems that work best for your brain, feel free to reach out at jenny@cognitiveslp.com.